24/08/57 Chesterfield (H) 2-0 Eastham, Evans
26/08/57 Sheffield Wednesday (A) 0-5 no scorer
31/08/57 West Bromwich Albion (A) (A) 4-2 Hughes, Hannah, Tait[2]
04/09/57 Sheffield Wednesday (H) 1-0 Evans
07/09/57 Stoke City (H) 1-0 Tait
10/09/57 Bury (A) 1-4 Tait
14/09/57 Liverpool (A) 2-3 Keeble[2]
18/09/57 Bury (H) 0-1 no scorer
21/09/57 Barnsley (H) 1-2 Thewlis
28/09/57 Preston North End  (H) 1-0 Spears
02/10/57 Huddersfield Town  (A) 1-3 Keeble
05/10/57 Burnley  (A) 2-2 Punton, Spears
12/10/57 Sheffield United (A) 2-5 Scott, Hamilton
19/10/57 Blackpool  (H) 2-4 Young, Hughes
26/10/57 Blackburn Rovers (A) 2-1 Young, Hale
02/11/57 Manchester United  (H) 0-5 no scorer
09/11/57 Leeds United  (A) 4-2 B Mitchell[2], Wright, Hill
16/11/57 Bolton Wanderers (H) 1-2 Smith
23/11/57 Wolves (H) 2-5 Redhead pen, Hill
30/11/57 Aston Villa  (H) 2-0 Wimshurst, Tait
07/12/57 Derby County (A) 1-2 Wimshurst
14/12/57 Everton  (H) 0-3 no scorer
21/12/57 Chesterfield  (A) 1-1 Casey
25/12/57 Manchester City  (A) 1-4 scorer tbc
26/12/57 Manchester City  (H) 2-1 scorers tbc
28/12/57 West Bromwich Albion (A)  (H) 0-3 no scorer
04/01/58 Bolton Wanderers  (A) 3-1 Wimshurst, Tait, Kelsey
11/01/58 Stoke City  (A) 5-1 Tait[2], Curry[2], Taylor
18/01/58 Liverpool  (H) 1-2 Davies
01/02/58 Barnsley  (A) 2-1 Thewlis, Hill
08/02/58 Preston North End  (A) 2-3 Hale, Young
15/02/58 Burnley  (H) 3-1 Hill, White, Casey pen
22/02/58 Sheffield United (H) 1-5 White
01/03/58 Blackpool  (A) 3-2 White[2], Casey pen
15/03/58 Manchester United  (A) 7-4 Curry[4], Hill[2], Davies
19/03/58 Blackburn Rovers  (H) 0-1 no scorer
22/03/58 Leeds United  (H) 3-1 Cooper, Keith, Curry
05/04/58 Wolves (H) 2-3 Taylor, Tait
07/04/58 Huddersfield Town  (H) 0-2 no scorer
12/04/58 Aston Villa  (A) 1-2 Eastham
19/04/58 Derby County  (H) 1-0 Bell pen, McDonnell
21/04/58 Everton  (A) 0-1 no scorer

NUFC finished in 15th place, on 37 points